Cyril Ramaphosa’s future in doubt after disappointing South African election

Senior figures in the African National Congress were on Friday debating the future of President Cyril Ramaphosa and discussing options for a coalition partner, as the depth of the losses suffered in South Africa’s general election sank in.

With more than 90 per cent of the votes counted following Wednesday’s poll, the ANC was at about 41 per cent, several percentage points lower than the performance it and most analysts had predicted and a tally that would deprive it of its governing majority.

The poor showing has complicated the task of finding a partner that would allow it to extend its unbroken rule in South Africa stretching back to 1994 following the end of apartheid.

It has also cast doubt over the future of Ramaphosa, who took over six years ago with a promise to reinvigorate the ANC but who has instead presided over its worst-ever election performance.

Mavuso Msimang, a respected figure in the party, said there would now be questions about whether Ramaphosa could continue as leader. “If the vote remains close to 40 per cent then people will suggest he leaves. There’s a lot of talk about that,” he said.

You are seeing a snapshot of an interactive graphic. This is most likely due to being offline or JavaScript being disabled in your browser.

Msimang said that, if Ramaphosa stayed, a coalition with the market-oriented Democratic Alliance was possible. The latest vote tally puts the DA in second place with 21.7 per cent.

But if Ramaphosa were pushed out, Msimang added, it would open the way for a deal with Jacob Zuma’s Umkhonto we Sizwe (MK) which was on 12.8 per cent despite being formed by Ramaphosa’s predecessor only six months ago.

“What business wants is a certainty which can only come with an ANC-DA alliance,” Msimang said, adding that some within the ANC would be viscerally opposed to a deal with the DA, which they see as both white and reactionary. 

The ANC’s tally of about 41 per cent with more than nine out of ten votes counted was well short of the mid-40s that had been expected and the 57.5 per cent it received in 2019. “The state of shock within the leadership of the ANC is amazing,” Msimang said, “but we had it coming.”

Given the scale of the ANC’s losses it would be difficult for it to form a working coalition without making an alliance either with the DA or the MK, political analysts said. Most of the other smaller parties did not get more than 1 or 2 per cent of the vote.

Paul Mashatile, Ramaphosa’s deputy and a possible successor, is thought to be more likely to favour a deal with MK and possibly the radical Economic Freedom Fighters. The Marxist-leaning party led by the firebrand Julius Malema was in fourth place on 9.4 per cent.

Gwede Mantashe, chair of the ANC, told the Financial Times there had been no call within the party for Ramaphosa’s removal.

“I would resist this with everything I have. You don’t discus the removal of a president in the middle of an election,” he said. Rather, he said, the talk of Ramaphosa resigning was something that was “being discussed by our opponents”.

Asked if the ANC would consider this after the election, he said: “This is not going to be discussed.” Mantashe said it would be wrong to consider this a “bad result” when the ANC had still obtained over 3mn votes, and there were new parties emerging in South Africa’s political landscape.

Lawson Naidoo, executive secretary of the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution, said Ramaphosa needed to “move quickly” towards a deal with the DA or he risked being pushed out by his own party first. 

“If they get rid of him they’re going to do a deal with MK,” he said. “Once the ANC starts mobilising against Cyril he could be out very quickly.”

William Gumede, chair of the Johannesburg-based Democracy Works Foundation, said: “Ramaphosa’s head is on the block here. They’re going to look for a scapegoat and it’s most likely to be him. He will have to use all his negotiating skills to stay in power.”

Ralph Mathekga, an independent political analyst, said the ANC’s likely result would put any incumbent leader under pressure. “Ramaphosa can expect more pressure than most, given how vulnerable he has been. I can’t see him riding this one out,” he said.